HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015 Unified Plan on Seawall IssuesCWCF
siE
HOME OFPEUCANiSMD CITY COUNCIL AGENDA TRANSMITTAL FORM
Council Meeting Date: 11 February 2015
Agenda Item Title: Unified Plan on Seawall Options
Recommendation: Staff recommends the following options/alternatives for
planning and funding Seawall deterioration.
Background: On 14 January 2015 council directed staff to present a
unified plan to identify Seawall repair plans, options, and funding alternatives. A
preliminary plan is presented that outlines the engineering requirements needed to
proceed with the seawall options. They are:
• Field review the canal system of impacted seawalls).
• Identify impacted seawalls within the existing southern canals.
• Create a map of the southern canal system with impacted walls.
• Drainage assessment of the seawall vs grassy slope for drainage capacity.
• Geotechnical assessment of impacted sites to identify soil conditions.
• Identify phasing of interim and long term canal features and mitigations.
• Meeting with SJRWMD on the phasing and options for wetland mitigations.
• Construction cost estimate of the phases and funding.
It is staffs position that any engineering analysis must be
outsourced to an engineering firm with specialized education and experience in this
area. Therefore, any initial engineering costs are considered an authorization to
start the engineering planning process. That initial appropriation is estimated at
$50,000. Staff will follow the RFP/RFQ process. An engagement contract with a
qualified engineering firm will be submitted to Council for approval/award.
If Agenda Item Reauires Exaenditure of Funds:
Total Cost: $50,000
Amount Budgeted in FY 14/15: -0-
Amount of Appropriation Required: $50,000
Fund to Be Utilized for Appropriation: General F n
rp ese e
Administrative Services Department Review.
Attachments: Presentation by City Engineer
City Manager Authorizatio .It
Date: 04 February 2015
1
CDJL
AV
:.Crq
-.
ANAL
111:
amm
v
a
a
.� a1 tiw^� ,� '� -r _ � `•�.r Y���..; ,, =s:y ;mss; ,+r:,��"' .•1~. rS�er
�• � ' "'� ..I��,:� .%x �.�:•-',c� ;,•f . SII
._ -,r, y _rte• f G.�� r' _: �']r�v.
'.» _ s.,•tirs • y.,� .ter .• ���?; ••t `.,i'.
ji
;Ltµ-�� +:Jj _.:.e.. - ,-.ti ri�.(+,Z•M1!•. .. ,SS,,sll.!.:r�C";s .f �•� 1 .?
+5� :•xi:p'} •• ,tir"` Z �x..'I .fix ( 7 ;
`'•.mss' f�a_._.: ' 4tw'� `r 4 �� •. �..' '� a, •^ .i
:�•. -!, �..�,�, r -r••: - _ ilii.;!••
T �, � ter` '• '� .r•. .'r .tet. Al; r�CS •e:
ISI
.�- _"" � • � : �.... � +ter
'�•" 1 r
PL.
-` � u '
(t.�� ', I h~i ��' �!�;; `,ry�,.}.�; rs:y .Yy`µ%=+:i^•�:�?".r -. ��r;:�i� f•s*'kt °�'ialiy'�} f:!'F!•:'l� ..,jry:e.+j �•I�lr .._ � 1� .fi.'•`�z: 7 € � S! 3E; S (
• �C, �• ems' `; .1'. ';}y ' ' s -? }'1rr -t S.i �'J;: :•.�, �( I�srl 3t �,F�yl j: Sid'�;!7' j �• �.t7 �S i�
`�,,. ; ^�'�' ;,*: .5�' • *I t Y•y:r r '`'•' lr•(irly'•�1•' 7.i!" �' }.'Y" Pit • + 1... �;, •I
• , r+w: � ',• tot• r' �^.'-:•�i; i f tv3 fS.��{{. jj.}�
',1yn�L� T.i •• \ k, i•ay�ti�+'j y!'.i 7y !-i�,ga+• ' f�i :.rlr [: l•'.M`•� •jl�,. f- 'f• ^t ',
;�ij•,i.;:;l. • �., tij';��,��• ' i S i,� ,;� y`rti=K�l �1, ���i >� �:.'4` i. 5+.�•. �+•qq: y";}• � ,
1 : syt'}' : � 'I-. :e(y.."•.«.r �,. � C,i•;..y' �f. !! s:t• {' � 2ti!'f• � j i` :' i,. �-• } ;
F.�,.=_�:•' i 1:;: • ?.�?.'. 1'tH,...r�C: y ,�.:.,.'j�'; »� ''+' 5.L
•��: Oto
'N; �` '��:.a i=�,.ti ..�t.ihr`;
": A r •X j3 (t'liill:.•. (• fl�dir �li*�r'•� lw,'p'�,•.iri eAI (tJ ly�'h.!' ! (j{j�ij'I•I`�
{{i�•;= •. ': 1 � .r, � +�,,,�j�(� !,,.r �y I st• (,
'%'dS ;,j;tni�= r:+ L;'.iJ�.�'''��'�h:.'yiE'ra�: iy � i'•'N 4n?�c JS, �`' _ �•''�'�'�`�' ��N �.
.., s • �x:r 1 tip+: j 1..�.
• SS�tii�.7, . ,,'• 3��1: �' ly.:••. 1{t �� `� .j ��y}, jI � 1 11'1x•.-+.
.. ri• ,, .. ., •F����•1 n1.: .1�A 1 ��1WWI
�;ti ��
:RS `,...•-.i�i� r` �i,rIr� s�jGit.rL i*' + Mr•l�;` fil 6'1; 1 +j f?�Lt�,',f�S,{,Y .� (jfY�!
�'.).:�i-'S:+l .�` i.t•:, }a •!: �i. i-' •�.� •�}(1 (€i'I \ iF1W a�l' 4� ,( i' i r, •� ^�.K!'"'• � !r +
'N �!I+Lirq
q��" t S tl"'iiES i}.+ CjNZ} is.,l�xr,��'
�~ 14''
iAMV
if
�„e.:� • i ! 4.:7.: • !�-•' r Fj ,11.E r: a y .e,(t •, i( ;+4
. ,; . ;...:y X14• � � �i! p.11� .,•., • i. ~,.
r,� ti;+ ,; i� +e' :��: 'i..r,t�:".�•��� � .�:.1 :'sr7 ki'E! }i .;•;•op+r{f+ r � '�
7r,tr i` �i'�V . ^c: 7,,:•-� +�y=�1(--q r;i::'' t,�.-j•i�j:(,��'.1 . .xP� i ��� }� (i ��(F� � !'S ri �IS
';��- c�4.. lj �,'yi•.'•�t;_7�G: �"ii:; yry.•.�1 5 '.:';� Z it 7+}4is•••r '}!? r t l ,
'i`.' rr } . `:! <,,.•.: •(.:.ik
a,lIa.
4 �wj ' '.:`i..t. •[.y �:~�'S�j YS/�lr5 lf0+ � L�� }. iv,'."" ><ti'�f t ai ._ !i pp..r '•TMi!j r:�
,zf}�� "'nt:. 3;:., �• i' :;. ' '•d�';;� �' �.�'•`,�� �':.�. 'I f1
•.Cts. .: v� 'S � II ..r
ri ori[ rs` J 1 •+x : i ' F y,
��» °:. • ,I•r •F ti.i•, t:(-�•..t {rr".;IJ•){jjt�%��� 1�j1°J[r.,;.. ,!,' •pl Ifi�� (..I; • �[{t' , , _+ • ''a;l:' 1,
::Ir]'♦"..�\-❖+;;•u': .it .I. ril' �' j;!'.• ]. I 1. .: �((
• ay..•..�;::.� � r ' L;;�`e; ; :fir 1�; rl ( w� . �.
.L "�.�'u,> i'ti•r 1�7':!�;Ih;('„�r'i��'�'}". i+�• :Ir +�� '. •. � ! . s�f�.�.,, {; !. . - •'�. ,-,� �L_: • jw fri •}
'_:-.•.`;.1:iA 1 �:: `l�:> ;•:.,:Ca,r,{,� .Ing
b:'' 'C ',• :r.a:.'Ji+(y�'v �,;' .y .tiff,• `` I•(1i1}• I:fl'�• t, r.. 1S r'tit•Nr' •
t�i,. t,►+� ��R. +.,�M ,� 1 r'.j lip
51"1 •T. �,1••. '.js:
�'L ,;,'3 ♦1 � ,a i�• rS"t� ^ti �' 11: .b.' Bfi It } •Is.j ;t, ' !jr .•'. •, .'av
. r (j
� ti.�•j1•�c� .iy t' 1R F7 I��} ; t � ! % i 1 i
;Ti't'yxµL•ysi„r4^l�C!� YhyIT ,1� ll. •t.. Y',:sr`'-'� I
1 f (( YY
�' Si, l}i+},11 �'„'''?FYN:jl, . •�S}J+i_ r 'r•� I t'�, •jy IjEr' .r •r _ f+• }•f
:!ZIn+t�:l I 1,rY�t[} f4..A
c::'�p �,�ft �� � rr`� I �ti•���� i ( i1 Y .{ .V�� '�.�'�i$.• i ' ..Cl. • pi' w `rL•4'L r j (• �� ,
t �'tl}�:�::,:i t � �:. .'^�{YS �i i ;!i �y • el.. '�"."n A}R•:s s;!' ..r�4 (.
S v�f✓t Pt r S 1. itfi �ti....' znu.c .,•
Eli
Lw� ha. 1,�•ki
o+••+y t, ,_,}�Y 1,�• J i ( ' !:, r I i f-t � ..
,q I' 9.
=#�ti,j+-r-°'� �1 i ;f 1 !•(' f �!+1i( i.'. i. I'4'• ri,I'-•}` ,1 •.I.r �� �i ��
' .'�u.� /�+a r�� � ;! !. S• �, ' ,�y Irl .il;rnl s If3��I�lei'�(�4' I t' i a
;�`la;l1'*.:.:j�L ~t }!y'•(►st� �'`�Y �1. 1'S ( i :1 ! '!I �i, �s I++ �}+[ !' it .�.�� . •�- � �,.
„t,} Sr'.•1`•,?-.'ls��:[}}';�i.l � •L ' I . i �..' I, .I>,? I � �1 11 • r . ���!'r�Lr� u�1� ll.lil:. L ::i ;•,
y-���'.�. � •cjlfiy r�� 1 ! 1 1i 11� .;�f v. ���,t�'j��k•y ,F r`., I. •.'?I �''•. �' �I t�
Olt" �:.�j-t��p.alll.-f ' 1 ,i ' 1 ' :{” •i''r'•"``}1 Ip 'A'
�sy�h• t-i��f. �'�=�T��' ' , , .1 , I 1 I. i , r�' 1i� i `i1 }f`• 'Y `
?•l�#'3,��oiN`�,I::iIt9: rli;�ry;(! F { {. , 'y . ' L t • � �.. •.. i . ' ,,� 1 N .
We
�ELeY MiI K�•� I ' l i; •;i: � i.•tl Tl ;pi
jy1.9 1 r;y0ti ! y
•1 {1.�'I!>I .�:�� 1� '- •r •rte'• •�. i
! E .M .J F ��j '�� { •1Z'1 i ri • titi �y...
'-'>��,fi':s}(•Iij•I�: 'I�;1;.'•+�Iiii��.�_] ::`,: , •r" -•e. ! .r,.�.l' t I r�
..l 4 • ':J
i%•`'1 F:i,Sf� .f lei �j�1S - f•,"~+�•' �:. - i. + - i' r
'•� • i %'S'ij'• n .. •
�• 11 i7to
,g,f.
�'1 .irrS�Y: �. : � 1 - y r. ' S - ° •` .. _ � X11
i!ww, elf'«�.�3(;�tlH,,7 . '� . � . r �• _ I ` n�'ii� 1,, •_ -,1 .'1 r `
•; ei,: , r
;'!•.+lt?ark:.,• ' . ' r �� _j ' r • i' i •. .. it 1 . {
• ...�.- -' � fir . � � "� r' 4 /�; ;
to
oo
!!{{ �[•+�r3r�s•� 33 • /•. ,frJrrr�II' ��.J �iF""y��){i� fdf t
���1T,:7ti n��l'gaw. Y, Ir 1 I':1!°{rf� 7 i;•. l
• ��iillll::•iiJJ,•' �ypt� I�; i�r :•ii [ S :r j 11��� 1 . /�',•i r j•'•.
.s JL :,r r 5_• ��, • f� . }f,�' �. rk� ��v tl.����,I • I Vii;" f •if
4fyi,'•
01
Vill F,
r '�'4-i iy` SFe'�yr�•r�"iy.a; > > 5.�: ��1,� F�
1p
je
;r �%+,� {,, •ass.- i...IP,4l;:: k�.�� � ���•1' / �' `E• �t' • `� 11
_'•;� � ;fag's _ _
jf•41 'TI' u•rl •r..:r'
�•, !'t -Y:• [LYS ��� '•4 phi s - 1
•i:�1Y •7; ryt :`
• t e�. f �.i,� J•2 •�� •r
• •. �.7',l fir_ - �+ ;��3'l rpt' �•.
.. l � � 1- lrs� Fi r ►.
{1 � ;fir"i��'r �;.+' ' �•
.,• r�i r�: ..
Allit
.7 ,�i• ��, Ff .1•
i7�j}tiv •�y�F,'Ir'r. ; ^J1 ..�'P�•i',•.Kli
Vj
ll x ��',•':',..'
i jj`Ifrfy i i iT1•� ..i , � r.
IN
I.a.
;I
's _-
lk
nD
's _-
lk
11
0
4
L
T
-
t_ Re lace_exrtn =aa : =al=1s
-_ JfD%c_
-Slope bank -W/ iti ations
S R�V1-MDMitigations - -- _ 50%.match:_
H..:brid.. 11 :: :, -
a and,Slo e5
R MD
4
W+
.
w _ .
w_ �=r
HOME OF PELICAN ISLAND
r,
.• • L `..' E I
l L-1.'r . + �•i w'......I C. + �Y 'r 4'1 0. i 'I
$1
'(fr-� `� �MSi.f7R,7� j'� ''`'tet•'! + i;es t jt
Clri,"I :filL�-i�ilT _'•'ii:;i v.~Y ..Y;al«Ir
_�� «.- 'yS1 tl - }1»s«�-�. +�.`■..t.gl1_ Oi ` _ .Y.i:s iiia t!aias�
Iwo
KL
., ,'T °f r�• .+� _ . r .>y-a s 0 s a c:t i _ i +�rtt• i•ta. 7iQ -.�. a.
y », _•� .,.« ..ri--g-=t4...-i , C »
Z-1 wi■�u r w�7 - » k ~�.'l l -a:C ! y ! ri7 '' .s
1$ y � } R iL >? A � • 7 d �k.l....:� � � ti«I ..t Z.� �,/�I ,.�..1. ' ....•• � �w� C � s y � a �.-i�:««i.��� 'il 11'•i'�s j r '
t,l• F,�Jr � #' }r���i e ' i fi :212 n ili'S :3}Q _ .,l � �!• i i S'� l+.�l �y . 1 a. .
r -..J 'l ! •iii { J i t tt }� .•' i - f ' 7t fI i) �,,� �... _. a L`t ♦ ' �/�
�._` ,a. `u., ,+e.� i p '-j« ���+'.tw=••ie 'r '� •C ! Ii } . �� �•..1«i M' i \/J
` 7�. Zi i ` %\ /� �'„ i . `'~ ' :. �♦ I
7 V Y y� �y' ,� `•• •�_ _� Qt �- _ j e i N } •�M1y�r •' t I 3
?� Lh!�� r;; _ . ✓'; :�r ,i'•1 ��•t� tI` • 1 M.� �r' ( . '• V•Nj�w Y i�1 V . _ M i . 1 � �••1 ()'• �r.F.r�•« I ••-�'.a � � ���{F'
•�«,1•��t.♦�1\ •' ��'/'• w •�.` lftaf• a i a l L4='i i- E • • i a 3..e�; Y• 1 �'�s �•.�,�„ 'a F . f.'S•ia
G �j,�•,'1 'R- {~^`' Y %ra��rr �. J a«•�!.' i} `/, N�ti�/\ •C\ r � +. � •� = t«.... `-i.� '�N{..¢ "✓ 4 : t>< . w�' '
`t+�� � 4 �t I' � /� w iL'•, �., .�' . •• t} y�..ln�'.. •r i - I d ' ��'1 •'•" � ( a � • � 0 t777"'w , � �� .�y'
%i X1 e ' t� \ t . C \II\l �w•ti S i�' CY C ia. ••ij ,♦i� r 1 ' i 1 �! i 3;- i- T_� •g"� d, d \/�
---'---'-j• ti �'° �, b t\ Y�'�'i�tl a t, V•a'/u n n S Y ~J ! = Lam' �•t�f N' t7 i�
i w fit '11 � /,�"� t qty xtr i•�i6• lt' `�/.I� Yw' + �� � •• � �• 1} �..4 � � 3 / /f_ ' . " C / 'n tl,��/
r �r' •a. R1 •.� %�Y r\�a1, al',\`t• � \_� v •tl� ; tl 1 _\i e`✓{=i\ ���j lA1'+
/ r 1, iG; / �_/ . �' • t/�/{ iS /'� Y✓i n r . . ! ... y t •�/ �/ ■\ .i•n.. �.
/• r i�l` �Y, ' fl. +a r•S S'�''►, �}/ r'1 Lt -r.�l i{r). Va7��t�• w �s .L Y.. �� J,1t/i _ a''�t\$�• •/t,%t�
�y tr .� a• Et �a .�\i ' �a /'�� l• %o ? Y •' _�� •.�..'- = 3 - tl a �. ��, %[ it ?.
a s , it .�, , t yl /a
r.
/ ,r �7� � � 0 4,'r►•'^�J "� \' $\i�i!' �\���/. •�t/ _,�'�, �r�' � !d i...S � R ' ! •1 = \ E O `= �,/\ , �'C i• / ►..'?i z
•% ..a a {ji 1L r^. w' ri �r\a�""C s r; k, � h a t "" i-- i -+- A t /;,+ .
$ i p 1��`r�•}•� ♦ 1 a ti ♦ '� �C �'i✓ 6 1'• . Lti �,�rt
C a ��.. ! �,••i •r rS ? '/• i�%l i v ,+� • A _ � Rw�♦��. / � •"' •., �' � F♦��- „ �• rr „
tri A. rt Yt Y `}.'•
1 1 ¢ �/_ �• �/(
Lo' 1\ ✓ y •'�'Y `./
. i l � s � l i � j „' / I' i ` J r•�+,r•i , t\y T' �0 `ii y/,.,� , a+4• �%='1; \ •^ 'i \ r \ r �'J a. a� N i't//y • . ✓w' '2 .J - , Y ` L .�.
r t 1,• ""( i'".y t �,� R y� \y \ �» / !' : 0 -�� i t/ �y,' • y. + 'rti -' a ''• r C� . 1 \
��-� ! If\� �•ft•''':��;Y� ``�•� a�`�rZ / /tit\ � 1 .a�, .a��, ro�ti�■/t` a����a lE.\s
..t s� fl } a : � f`\••�r 1x\ti'< ;�'�" apt,, ss l %` �` \ �1 t ,X . Y ■ '�, a C
t r l•.. r t,• = a �a
r .., S S,,.I r „�y � '✓/'\ \ .. ��1 s ''� e- . ��r � Q.� S�,�l•��•q�` /'`J_ ! •��t � s rs 1 "r? O
'�.r' •� .• rt !\�r�E�t /a•t\ 1•,� i `�. � ■ •\ ` =.•t w/♦ Y 0/S i� • � L
"� «}., .t. .t•;�,� tfy�'t/y �a T."\�•. t.r' .� r� t.�i. �. ,� ti�r•Y ■� ; d/ rl�i +t d,. `r
�n_ �.,;,.xv Y i \i f��N�,'•� t d ��'r♦ / i tt ~ t,�.[ 0� e��t E\ � t \�,y �•� ` �: J'•\•� s 1 'l
q � i . ,�-•,;'� 1 s,,, = _ V t * t.."t.r� . � . �i;y 11 � ••�. 1.r'd }�• :i •Vy \ R \( i ' �•i a �'.'/' �G�� •i
/
._....�._.«...» N \ +-',Q` �•� s{ t k✓'�1�� y���s/�"•. �" •Y!�'�s \�E• � / :•T ��'�/ �%'.� a� �pr
S s 1� ?,' 1 /r. \� �� • �• ��••''�a a ..�' .\ .•� p �/ a 'y,\■,• r ;,v.. s t r d � � � a � ` � a i
•1 y/ k� .,t,•, , ia^tN L' f'l�s '. . '.{ /` . �1 3 t/ y r N ,rY .a w� - y , vS \ A t fr�\s'
'1a0�. ty •� ti � \/ •AN •{ \
+.Y� , �:I �\� . . b i•' :,s Ora t�'•+ 'ul ,✓_ aX'T
. ���/;\ �a� `� � ��\-,•`' .!'\tt\ity�"\r\� tl st r. c�3/ i� k �,Y • t Lt 'c • �,,: sf ��� r�i at� Y\"\ _<<
N.
I �d�Sfl.r�a n. :'r,?f? 1�.rs t�•r'r'r>�tl✓' ��y!' y t d' =� = c\r
• ,.\ t : f !\�tC t:>.> r f.)(. \ >a/tts ✓.� M g'�, e
,•'tAC r r1• 1i✓ `��a� tf �•,•' Cr; /r •y�, vN ,i\
�..__.. .�,/ tes l i i,• p n�t.�J;. \f7� t.�/ ("tia�.,Y -x) ``S•"\�i�
t r • 7 \� / •,+ /++.1 x 9• •5 • � s S s i . i, I 2
♦ iL/ •/x� . r t f.A ..�� Y V . Qt .`. •• (" \ i t ay`�♦ tr •' l6 ` Y��• + : i�%a O II `
'" ✓/�eti,� 't a. /` /a. ii •�,/rrf � � 1'( t,✓/ i k �•-la - .''��� n• .• l• �� \ r 1`[rr, >,,!; •'`�' �z��,./ j!�
"�•,�;i f%i' /�L' iii 1 • t/ k� „\,�/a��'✓ T, 1 �� arC\\\111 .•( 'IV�CC�\/ r tl,lt.Y
�a r St
V.
in�yr /�t / i t A Y \/ v tl, •.
.«"•�'- 1 rr 'Y. j*i*, 1 s.•!.\; •fi' •'•a�' ♦j••� •'�:`y�ta ,�✓`'t,t`!/`t •\ �
! :r% tl t� 1 Yrs\r \ .'n, t 1! ,ir /� ''+� 0,k R� A� f '
it ..7-' it, \ a . �( t� t y �•�js`t Y r t
�' • 7 t i r-'i ` + \� yat i w� y r I {} r \\_♦ a , • , ; ir,•t a'♦/ • /� d\ l V. r
• T �/` t 'F . Ii, ••tet( r- t '' G ! ■ R\ ✓ �1' Y sli \ 3• u X �[
1 �r :_!•� •Yq w♦%•v'�>� :♦ '&i \"a�/ r.t:�.•`'S',.. \t7'/♦ r�'•� �• ••1 i' \ t.• •/o �t
1 d . /p ,•u�•
.92
y;'rr , §.� ij •r' r \ 0, S =r tY\ a Y `Y r� ■ ♦ i
Jl z�!!1M_ _ �s.� / -•'t �'� ' `r y.h a% ' !�t'� i S: �,t t ° it " �/ 11%
; \�Y' ". !
j•�, c.�' • syr '4 et.\.\ - f
w . I •• _ r.. �;/Y Y •! / \ `'1v C� f l` itt t' 1 Q , /E 'r t \ 2 • 1;'`'Y ' I
".'s''�' . a•-{` R '`' / � r'r' � ~1 !'r! 4! i ��' � a •� s'N i♦j%�+� `�♦ S N � Y \.r\•� dt•,/' .•1 \ ` % /�t • • Cr�N � : } � j
(`•.yda'� 3�i �\ \ f• r Y ,♦'
As
%I
�t x;'\t�,�•;.f ;-NO,' �1 f f ~. ' / =1tjY.%�.•' , ~ti '{ �r i}r '
$1 jL 1 Y L �
V' t t y'�•d '�( s,•\ �1;♦If: ^/�d a.t ( i ar a f + • » fl� % y + ii ;',`
a \ a a C) \ I • 'rC . tit tl,• h. :�
i7 � �M .� r,. �. N.- • ^ \ di' !.� � ? \. , k�•..�;�>,,' ti %dI'Y \ �✓� /.A R r i �• � t ' , !'•:.
1„ ri r:•%,�.11A�Y� ti,� ��L •i/ i ♦• as / 'wt �L rtYr i r /a O
• " t. 1 w , _ A 4j..i. ( of ♦, .% I �t �J �ti �! f) �j i t// ` ty11.i '-r �a •\J �� r'.' d �'a'�yfd.. r'i✓a t '
E `� t I $ t r t11 . I e��,/a� �3 r t i \♦\ : A ,' 'C ! l i•/ �` /alt , r �•,/y"tom\'�i;, \r• \t{':
i y ( d w '0 �,�'1 4.+«:l t •'.fr-. ��%t r/. : Yr�y±! y� 'fie a qt /�•\ /ti S.".r- r'\\�.•��Q
_�>y�l��'�rc` > t ,�� ♦ �E j,�' `, j�fr { �;'..
a r wi I a txIYIwy,: `=h�-•�'�, �slfi t�= c i Y; i •"' q C
i..�,. .b. ..«.iE'w Y'1ja qs�a-f —xldl•) f,Ot• f= ra'� R}� �♦ iJ•. ,ilt� r't�tiC {i\ •Yy _ _ ��•�
%i ` r L/ ••!. .�' \/ice • ter 1 •'� 10 �.
"" � ��••Y , » --'«r •'� � � � � l l ...i«:� .....3r1 tt �.� � 1{ : moi. 7 i \ a � •1•a • > ✓� ata Eby
Y`�'r' k :�1�-T o?� +y �,)\ tt�S '\M,-\` Y ia•� /T- f s,�' sty�!•`Yri(r `1C' �`('� m\ j -',�
+•. _� g }Y w , i'•J % `'•%• Y %• S r •a ti ` ter[
rr't /a�r ka
CO
p' r> Y r " ,y� E•�T rti tm• ✓td '•Y i�• r
«.\ � �.'i. i..n. • J t «►. 1 - ../� Y�1 K • �' �. n ' �i�. /'t r' (- ` ' � any :1O�i�r n lo�
71far'-. � %j• ••• i, •' • '� tlt tr�r�� +'' i H•�'`' ♦ ° ..♦'1=!• •' \ C `'� frr��',.1-,`x�a � 1 'tt� I
w I .� y, C •.' r. •, i � Y . � \ . \' ti,�� %• C r n�� x lr .•''`` 5i �Y }� � �:
` `'r.•r '�/,�w�; f •'�.�f tj. fA+\a„.\ir ['w �st�,i`a ��/�•' ice- I .(
• t'- *N„ '�,/% / �•1w'\�. • tet`, ���frll. • �''k /» 1� •� 0♦ / i� � 4 A �]1r �S►�;rV' Smit' �., ;,fit
oe
R 1
} y .. t* /:` \ '`I'•'F` ri• rrlc t'�✓t ii�:. !a. �� ��\i�r .. E•. V„\fi ///\ � ij�t�'
t ..J�:�♦. �� e l,J�.♦�1.'..;�2 :� �rY�i�J �y+t�y i��/�S.iy r.�� �' Y �� w Y•�'`i �+{i.:
:••. ?rt ay�'%/; w �r Q•�. �/•t� �'� 1}�i:; �": ti � i�'siiY`„�. �8\�`�•'' � t.
.« «.. _ « ....j ~It•'J� BtN..i i `fd S»•.lt}t= t »« fI(3a//�l'C\?" d\�.>• p•\0,/tp♦ {�
_.' �'' • C o r ✓'•a 7� , ✓/moi C { a}
.t : = -� ..� J ' a� r1 'i ` A',,k •a E �'� } tl. d y_«\a
j _ ����• `� a�\r'ta'• . tC a Y \ t ♦ ir+s t t:s
t 1 A }r•� •% s�•�,��Y�'�' i .h��C =r/ y{�'•� � n'J 4 t5 g ��. �j •mow T t�L ''i 'l f / {' �
F• aWs �'~ , � w t �,,�.`.I�',t/\♦ a, t �,, ,r •t,,.' ,tl\'yF/y Cis ; I . and � / '\ r�'� �Y .= i .•=r� Y {�}�
I, i ti• J't ��w r/t \ /\ S� r wti a `� ' i���{ ('Y ?, i i1.r�+!`{�t•a�''t� j'!1
i 0 3 d f♦i ;�\,. t• elan ■ YC\ j.r O 1n Sjt♦ t ayy4� : V i/� •ti./ r'a
-\1 d•. M.Sa r ,•'
i!i ♦;,• ;r•'i` ••rY R�\E .t ir•: a ; ixti f•-� a ti,lj£s, ^�'� '� 1 �� y s ilk
�....-�..�..«...........� ! y p x�\ r� �`�•�w �` X .y �`'�..�'r0 �. \ 'fir-• 1=�t ;�'
ikiiT
{ �" 1 • .r•' :\: \/ r 0 .1 a.X \4 0s '8 M ✓6,. w /1t r"r y •wA ...�,�
yr •t`/ijr,,�''�N'q •'� = a��frili�•4 r•-�••r
�`'� 1 s _ r•-"1
' �,�.. �- .�•' 'r ;,A .% a� .�..'••� t r� is ' S 1 Y •t" u«•1,,../"• '' i
Z; / A t ::•+�• •'_ i- 'i• •. j . i i ��� .'�v ti '«..� tt t4 -� c~•s ! � .r•-
j '•'f a p t _'•' E ti .. `� 1j -4 ■ 3 '- X 1. r i (--„(1 �.!`\ E ♦ ♦• �• tom•^ �,,,,••
11«- F �:••_'• ► :Y...rr.a ...•,FiFii-- e i `/� .'•�..,••T-• t:
j �' U e�o•cla�al'•''d i •}(TM ' •.:�' 11-,1 "r '.s}a_ ii. f�'\��.ii tliA::
.. : S�-i ti..««.•.... •asvw-saw-•-` ' t,.... � i I•� ! it tl~!" � :■i' i'.. r':�- t! � i i N� .... �. \. iii 1..,�•..